Martin Luther: Crisis of Faith


Martin Luther is one of the most debated figures in all of Church history. His role in Church history was clearly driven by a personal crisis of faith. The debate is whether his crisis of faith was caused by a crisis of faith already running through the Church, or if the way he resolved his personal crisis sparked a crisis of faith throughout the Church we haven't recovered from.
Luther was born to a working-class family in 1483 with a father who could be demanding and severe in his punishments. He was also whipped at school when he did not learn his lessons. These early influences would shape his view of God (Gonzalez 21).
While traveling back to college, he was caught in a thunderstorm that knocked him from his horse. Afraid of dying and going to hell, he cried out to St. Anne, the mother of Mary, and promised to become a monk if he survived. He kept his promise and joined the Black Cloister of Augustinian Hermits in Erfurt on July 7, 1505. He fully committed himself to finding salvation through the Church (Hagen 212; MacCulloch 605-606; Gonzalez 22).

Luther's fear of God and hell was not resolved by becoming a monk. The more he confessed his sins and did acts of penance to make up for them, including physically harming his body as monks did at the time, the more aware he became of his sins. He obsessively examined his thoughts and actions, making detailed lists of any sins he might have committed. He confessed frequently from fear of forgetting a sin. He pictured God as stern as his father and early teachers. He found he hated the God he saw as so severe (Gonzalez 22-24).

To help Luther in his anxious quest for God's approval, Luther's mentor assigned him to the recently founded University of Wittenberg to teach the Bible and theology. Luther achieved a bachelor's in biblical studies and a doctorate in theology before becoming professor of Bible (Hagen 212; Gonzalez 24; MacCulloch 605). He began lecturing on the Psalms in 1513, the book he was most familiar with because, as a monk, he structured his life around reciting them daily. He taught each Psalm as being prayed by Jesus, which allowed Luther to begin to relate to Jesus (Gonzalez 24; MacCulloch 606-607).

It was his lectures on Romans, begun in 1517, that offered a resolution to his spiritual crisis and the basis of the theology that would make him infamous. At first, Romans 1:16-17 stumped him: "For I am not ashamed of the gospel; it is the power of God for salvation to everyone who has faith, to the Jew first and also to the Greek. For in it the righteousness of God is revealed through faith for faith; as it is written, ‘The one who is righteous will live by faith'" (NRSVA). In his Latin translation, rather than "the righteousness of God", it said, "the justice of God". He had always seen God's justice as severe and was what he was afraid of. Yet here, God's justice is said to be Gospel or "good news". As Luther puzzled over what to make of this, he realized he should not read it as God's just declaration whether or not each person was just, but God's act to make each person just, given by grace and received by faith. It was not humans exercising what merit they had, but God giving Christians all the merits of Jesus, simply out of his own generous and gracious will. His realization would resolve his lifelong crisis of faith. He did not have to make himself just before God. He stood just before God because of what Christ had done for him (Gonzalez 24-25; MacCulloch 606-608).

Luther's new teaching did not stir controversy until he challenged the Church's entire salvation scheme, protesting the ways he saw it misused against poor Germans. At the time, churches issued indulgences, which were grants the Church would give out, confirming that certain sins had been forgiven and would not need to be paid for in purgatory. Pope Leo X approved Albert, Archbishop of Mainz, to issue indulgences as long as half the funds went to the pope's fund for restoring the Basilica of St. Peter in Rome. Albert assigned John Tetzel to sell these indulgences throughout Germany. He made exaggerated claims that did not match the church's own theology, such as indulgences made you cleaner than baptism, made you cleaner than Adam was before the Fall, and were as powerful as Christ’s cross. If you bought an indulgence for a dead loved one, they would be freed from purgatory. Many saw this as the powerful financially exploiting the poor (Gonzalez 26-27; MacCulloch 608-609).

Luther saw this system of indulgences as exploiting Germany's poor and contradicting the message of grace he had discovered in Romans. He wrote 95 Theses for debate and famously nailed them to the Castle Church of Wittenberg's doors on October 31, 1517. He said the pope should free all souls from purgatory freely out of love, and not for a price. The pope should give to the poor instead of exploiting them, even if he had to sell the Basilica of St. Peter. The Theses were quickly distributed in Latin and in German and stirred people's anger with church and state authorities (Gonzalez 27-29, MacCulloch 609).
The Church quickly tried to get Luther to submit to Church authority, though without engaging in serious scriptural debate with him about his views (MacCulloch 609). Political upheaval within the empire slowed down imperial response to Luther, giving him time to broaden his support (Gonzalez 32). The pope finally excommunicated Luther in 1520 and gave him 60 days to recant, but by now, Luther was convinced Church leadership was taking God's sacraments and using them as a trick on the poor masses. He publicly burned the pope's order. He wrote that the Catholic Church was an enemy of Christendom, argued to clergy that the sacraments they were administering had been perverted by the system, especially the Mass that had been turned into a repetition of Christ’s sacrifice. He argued against transubstantiation, but offered an alternative explanation for how Christ was present in the Eucharist. Finally, he argued that a Christian is freed by Christ’s undeserved death, transforming all Christians into servants of humanity (MacCulloch 610-611; Gonzalez 33).
Attempting to pull Luther away from these disputes, Frederick the Wise, the prince over Luther's area of Germany, asked Luther to write a Postil, a collection explaining all the Gospel and Epistle readings of the Church year to help pastors in their preaching. Luther worked on these with an aim of helping preachers proclaim the Gospel of all Christ had done (Lenker, 3-4). (These are the sermons that are currently being released on the Vintage Sermons Podcast).

Luther was summoned before the emperor, Charles V, at the Diet of Worms in 1521. The assembly showed him his writings and ordered him to recant. After considering, Luther acknowledged that, at times, he spoke too harshly, but he was convinced of his position from Scripture and would not take back what he had said unless someone could show him from Scripture that he was wrong. After a period of negotiating with the assembly of princes, Charles condemned Luther, but by then, Luther had vanished. Frederick, Luther's prince, had kidnapped Luther and hid him away at Wartburg Castle for his safety. During his several-year stay there, Luther translated the New Testament into German and began translating the Old Testament (Gonzalez 34-38; MacCulloch 611-613).

The emperor soon found his attention taken by civil war, rebellions that claimed Luther as an influence even without Luther's support, and invasions by the Turks. Under so much pressure, by 1532, Charles allowed the Protestants to peacefully practice their own faith in their own territory, finally bringing peace to Luther and his movement (Gonzalez 38-46), but also permanently cementing the division in the Church.
Luther's teaching is left behind in his many writings, including sermons, lectures, treatises, and catechisms. He especially wrote on the Psalms, Paul, and the Gospel of John (Hagen 213-214). His theology was firmly based on close readings of Scripture. In Scripture, we encounter the Word of God, Christ Himself (Hagen 214-215; Gonzalez 47-50). All theology is drawn from Scripture and meant to serve the Church's main task of preaching the good news of what Christ has done for us. Scripture is its own interpreter as Jesus and the Spirit speak through it, rather than the Church. When reading Scripture, he focused on the simple sense of the passage, found in its grammar. At times, he would use allegorical readings of Scripture to embellish a doctrine, but never to establish a doctrine, and he rooted his allegorical readings in the simple sense of the passage (Hagen 214-217).
According to Luther, the focus of Scripture is the doctrine of justification by faith, that Christians are in a right relationship solely because of trust in what Christ accomplished for us. He measured all other doctrines against this one (Hagen 214-217). Luther also drew a sharp distinction between Law and Gospel. The Law is God's word of judgment, and the Gospel is God's word of grace. The Law reveals what actions count as sin and how serious God takes them. Yet even in the face of God's stern decrees, He forgives, making the Gospel that much more surprising (Gonzalez 51-52). Luther's personal struggles prepared him to hear the stunning voice of the Gospel in the Scriptures, yet they also ran the risk of having too much sway over his teachings. He is exactly right to refocus readings of Scripture around Christ. Yet at the same time, he was very much a man of his time. Some contemporary scholars of Romans and Paul's other letters commend Luther for focusing on salvation coming from Christ, but criticize him for not critiquing the Bible readings of his day enough (see this podcast episode for an example). Like the Church around him, he was much too focused on how to go to heaven, rather than God's plan to restore creation, and thinking about salvation as something that is merited, either by our own works or by Christ's works. The medieval merit system doesn't quite map onto the New Testament.
A far more serious issue with Luther is violent rhetoric he made against the Jews in his later years. Luther was generally known for his sharp, biting rhetoric which could be vicious, but, unlike his harsh words towards Catholics and Anabaptists, his writings directed towards the Jews were later used in Nazi propaganda. According to some, Luther did not see Jewish people as ethnically inferior, the way the Nazi party did. He targeted their theological differences, but we cannot defend his violent rhetoric that bore real world consequences several centuries later in one of the most horrific and evil events of history.
So as we look at Luther's life, we see a complicated man who contributed to the darkness of human history, but also was a passionate reader of Scripture, committed to preaching that Christ gives believers all we need to know that we are secure in God's love, a commitment born from his own personal wrestling with God. His complex legacy is worth wrestling with as we look to God's love for ourselves.
To explore some of Martin Luther's preaching, check out the Vintage Sermons Podcast. You can find it on Apple, Spotify, Amazon, iHeart Radio, Pandora, Stitcher, Tune In, Deezer, RSS, and wherever you get your podcasts.
In the comments below, what about Martin Luther's life encourages you? What in Luther's life challenges or warns you?
Bibliography
González, Justo L. The Story of Christianity Volume 2: The Reformation to the Present
Day. New York: HarperOne, 2010.
Hagen, Kenneth. “Luther, Martin.” In Historical Handbook of Major Biblical
Interpreters, edited by Donald K. McKim. InterVarsity Press, 1998.
Lenker, John Nicholas. “Editor’s Introduction.” In Sermons of Martin Luther Vol. 1:
Sermons on Gospel Texts for Advent, Christmas, and Epiphany. Edited by John Nicholas Lenker. Baker Book House, 1983.
MacCulloch, Diarmaid. Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years. New York:
Penguin Books, 2009.



Comments